A lot of first-fill ex-bourbon casks intended for aging Lagavulin would be filled first with single-grain Scotch. Lagavulin has an oilier, fresher quality, while Laphroaig seems drier. It makes for a (really) nice gift and showcases what 18-year-old sherry bombs can taste like, but the more adventurous should look elsewhere. This is exemplified by their Islay Barley Scotch Whisky, which feels (and tastes!) I just need to get my hands on a sample of Laphroaig 10 and maybe the 10 CS. The more moss, the more phenols are released by the burning peat and the more medicinal flavor in the whisky. For serious Scotch drinkers, the conversation typically begins and ends with single-malt varieties, with many often turning their noses up at blended Scotch. Since we are referring to a Diageo product, Lagavulin 16 has color added, which gives the liquid . From Eastern Scotland try the Glendronach peated expression or, if you can find it, The Macallan Rare Cask Black Edition. Both Oban and Lagavulin have whiskies available at an alcohol content of 43% *86 proof), although Oban only has this strength while Lagavulin has 43% as the minimum. That also means more of the phenolic compounds make it into the final whisky. Today, you can find peated malt whisky from Ireland to Australia. Bruichladdich is a smaller Islay-based distillery, which allows them to take bigger risks than some of the more well-established brands on this list. Loch Lomond was established in 1814 and produces various single-malt whiskies of different ages. Try These Whiskeys, The Complete Buying Guide to Buffalo Trace Whiskey, The Most Exciting New Bourbon and Whiskeys of 2022, The 22 Best Scotch Whiskies You Can Drink Right Now, The Glenlivet Ndurra Peated Whisky Cask Finish, Glenfiddich Bourbon Barrel Reserve 14 Year Old. Once a quaint fishing village on the shores of the Sound of Kerrera, the distillery has found itself in the center of a bustling town and resort community that has grown up around it. Tastes like dried figs dipped. It internationally holds a spot as a really good entry level peated whisky. Dried herbs and a lingering soft sweetness when in the mouth with a light oak finish, he Singleton of Glendullan, 15 YO Single Malt Scotch Whisky. (182.86 per litre) A magnificent whisky. Springbank was founded in 1828 by Archibald Mitchell and today is owned by Mitchells great-great-great-grandson, making it one of the few independent distilleries trading blows with giants like Diageo. During the aging process, the flavors captured in the wood are infused into the single malt giving it more depth. The Macallan 18 Sherry is the perfect Scotch for non-Scotch drinkers. Its still the active ingredient in oral analgesics such asChlorasepticspray. Both have a medicinal quality on the nose. Ready to delve further into the world of peated whiskies? Interestingly enough, theres a bit more of the American oak in this particular scotch, which gives it more of a slightly smoky taste. All of these whiskies, with the exception of Insurrection, are well known, relatively easy to find and reasonably affordable. Historically, many Speyside whiskies had a peat component in their single malts. Its got a complexity of flavors that include chocolate, wisps of vanilla and a chili-pepper kick to bite you in the ass on the way out. Earned a Gold Medal at the 2013 International Wine & Spirit Competition. The Singleton of Glendullan, 15 YO, 40% ABV, 750 ml, $50 took the award for the Best 15 YO Single Malt. I get a light burst of grapes. But blended Scotch has its place in any home bar, particularly for cocktails, as you don't want to be drowning out the flavors of your 16-year-old single malt with liqueurs, bitters and juices. Whatever your tastes, we've got a recommendation. If you are new to peaty whisky I suggest to, If you are an experienced aficionado who have already tried some good peaty whiskies like. In Islay, maritime influences additionally affect the peat. It starts with the barley being collected from across Scotland after which it is malted. Appearance: Oban 14-Year-Old is packaged in one of the whisky industry's most beautiful canisters, a cream-and-blue affair adorned with a gorgeous, evocative line drawing of sea birds resting on craggy cliffs. Its well worth grabbing a bottle when they hit shelves. Talisker 10, Lagavulin 16, and Diageo are entities that elicit mixed feelings in me. However, Lock Lomond also sells other whisky types including their range of limited editions and single-grain whisky. This is a super easy-going Scotch, with delicate sweetness and little in the way of smoke, oak, or complexity. Its classic Offerman. The highest medal given out is the Double Gold. Highland Park 18 Year. SRP: $94.99. Finish: Long and spicy, with notes of figs, vanilla and smoke! Its 12-year-old expression has a delightful smoky sweetness, complemented by herbs and spices that show why this distillery has been around since 1846. Lagavulin 16 pleases crowds as the default good Scotch for a reason. Thats among the lowest cut points in the industry. Caol Ila, Islays largest distillery, is a go-to brand for easy, entry-level Scotch from the region. It was a good night; I was drinking something that tasted coastal while sitting by the sea and a campfire. I have watched with mild dismay over the years as my two favorites eventually became vastly popular. But the world of scotch whisky can get overwhelming pretty quickly, hence the previously mentioned complicated nature. 128. This simplicity lends the region to provide the base to many blends, though a few distilleries have been kicking out some peated options recently. I got turned off by the 43% abv and turned on by Lag 12 cask strength. This is a BETA experience. Laphroaigs Select Isaly scotch whisky has a bit of history to it. Oban Little Bay Small Cask Scotch Whisky $71.99 Buy Now. Large in land but small in output, the Lowlands is home to only a handful of distilleries, with Auchentoshan and Glenkinchie being the most well-known. Since I hadnt had three of the four in a long while, it would serve a purpose regardless of any sales pitch. Depending on how the distillation is managed, its length, the amount of reflux produced, and the cut points used to obtain the heart cut, the ppm phenol in the new-make spirit can be from a third to two-thirds less than the original concentration in the malt. In addition, the distillery uses a small still, nicknamed the wee witchy, in which the heads and tails of prior distillation runs are redistilled. Bottled relatively young after spending 10 years in a mixture of first- and second-fill bourbon casks, and second-fill French wine casks, its an aggressive Scotch. If you want pronounced medicinal, smoked fish, disinfectant aromas look to the western islands, Islay in particular, or Western Scotland. Since a portion of the wash is distilled two and a portion is distilled three times, the distillery claims that it distills its whisky exactly 2.81 times. We recommend thinking of each bottle of Scotch as falling somewhere along two spectrums: from light to rich; delicate to smoky. While its great to taste on its own, the fact that its 80 proof actually makes it great to pair in scotch-based cocktails, if thats your bag. From there, its easy to move along those two spectrums to find bottles you like. Flavor hits with dried fruit at first, followed by pear and apple shrouded in baking spice and a gentle tad of smoke. Great Scotch? Between the butterscotch and caramel are the mocha notes I get on the nose. For example, it must be made in Scotland and oak barrel-aged for at least three years. Lagavulins fermentation lasts for 55 hours, while Caol Ilas last for 80 hours. Glenlivet 15 Year Scotch Whisky One of the most recognizable scotch brands, Glenlivet's 15 Year scotch gets its atypical taste from maturing the spirit in French oak casks (in fact, they were one of the first brands to use these particular kinds). The peat pretty much saves this whisky. Glenmorangie Nectar d'Or. Peated whiskies are quintessentially Scottish. Its only lightly peated, and it undergoes an exceptionally long fermentation. The balance continues maturing in ex-bourbon casks. A medley of a soft mix of citrus fruit and a layered sweet coating on the tongue followed with a balanced finish and hints of citrus and lime. Peat Monster, from Compass Box lives up to its name and so does Big Peat from Douglas Laing. Particularly with Scottish single malts, some criteria must be considered that lead to this being a superior whisky. Most of its malt is also produced at the Port Ellen Maltings, but the peat is drawn from Laphroaigs own Glenmachrie peat bog. All 4 variations have an alcohol by volume (ABV) of 43% (86 proof) and all have a light amber hue to them. I just havent decided which. Oban 14 anos . Everything you need to know about Scotlands favorite brown spirit, including important terminology and a cheat sheet to the best bottles across all price points. This whisky is the holy trinity doing the 4 hand reel in your mouth. Its also smooth, caramelly and surprisingly easy to drink. . Scotch can only be called "Scotch" when it's made in Scotland in the same way that wine can only be called "Champagne" when made in the area of the same name. Oban Whisky distillery was established in 1794 by John and Huh Stevenson and was named before the town in which it was situated. (As a side note: as Diageo and Talisker continue to grow, I hope they dont shorten Taliskers 65-hour fermentation in wooden mash tuns. Talisker 10, while also well-known today, is still an old reliable. Its a great option for people who think they dont like single-malt Scotch. The whisky does not carry an age statement, but it includes whiskies up to 40 years old in the blend. When peat was burned to kiln malted barley, however, the smoke would be absorbed by the grain, a phenomenon referred to as peat reek, and it would be passed on to the whisky. Finally, dont ignore the peated offerings from the specialty bottlers. Made in a combination of bourbon and sherry casks, Bowmores Islay Single Malk 15-Year Darkest Scotch Whisky produces a final result thats inherently dark looking, but also extremely rich in flavor. But maybe its a case of me just trying the same batch of T10s in my market. Most of the time the smoke produced by the burning peat had no lasting effects on the whisky. I end up taking them for granted, which allows me to spend time and money on other spirits. The great-great nephew of William Mitchell, the founder of Glengyle Distillery, reopened his familys distillery in 2004. The Best Kinds of Whiskey That Belong on Everyones Bar Cart, Sign up for SPY news straight to your inbox every day. The actual menu of the The Keg Steakhouse + Bar. But I have samples of the Dalwhinnie 15 and Cragganmore 12. Best Budget Scotch. In general, bottles coming from Islay, such as Laphroaig and Ardbeg, are the smokiest. On the nose: Slightly bolder and fuller peat when compared to the Talisker 10. Not only that but I know in a lot retailers in France theyll have there standard size bottles of single malts all next to one another and very competitively priced. Scotch whisky is produced in one of the five areas in Scotland. The peat and smoke are just right. Diageo does these, classic malts of Scotland, box sets. When referring to Scotch, use the term "whisky" and not "whiskey.". But I found it offered a more balanced and sweeter note after sitting out and aerating for a bit, so take that for what it's worth. Balvenie 14 Year Caribbean Cask. Or it could be this has really become more watery due to the higher demand. Tasted like wet cigarette ash What is unusual about The Singleton is that each of the three brands has a specific geographic area where its sold: Glendullan is sold in North America, Dufftown is reserved for Europe and Glen Ord is exclusive to Asia. You asked! You may opt-out by. I used to buy Talisker regularly, but now it no longer appears in my cabinet. Bottle Price: N/A (paid $14 plus tip for a dram at a St. Petersburg, FL bar). Given that we are unabashed fans of Scotch, our team has spent the past several years tasting dozens, if not hundreds of bottles, both professionally and on our own personal time. This is a little deceptive as this is a measure of the ppm phenol in the malted barley. Others do paid-for content with brands. Lagavulin is aged for 16 years using ex-bourbon barrels. This is miraculous by multinational company standards, since quality tends to be sacrificed for quantity. Balvenie 14 vs Lagavulin 16: Discover Which is Better for You! Aberlour, 16 YO, Single Malt Scotch Whisky. The whisky is matured in both bourbon and sherry casks for 16 years before being married together and bottled. All scotch whisky seemingly has a deep and long history behind it, but Bruichladdich puts that history to use, literally. The vapor is collected and cooled down to create the final whisky solution. It was only a few years later that the town was named Oban after the distillery. These barrels will infuse the whisky with an amber color and tasting notes from the bourbon. Color: Apple juice from concentrate (Yes, again. An unpeated scotch, there are strong floral tasting notes, while still remaining dense and complex with each sip. Score: 91/100. Highland Park 12 Year Scotch Whisky $56.99 Buy Now. Tyler Duffy, Associate Editor. Think of the difference between smelling an open bottle of Pine Sol and smelling a dry pail that formerly held a solution of Pine Sol and water. Start by pouring 1 to 2 ounces of whisky into a bourbon glass and swirl it. Monkey Shoulder. Lagavulin 16 costs more and so it should considering the age and sherry. A very understated honey note appeared with much perseverance. Personally, I love the Uigeadail more, but not by much. $148 AT RESERVE BAR. Its a very well made whisky. Ian Hunter was the last direct family member to have ownership of Laphroaigs distillery and was said to have traveled to Americas beloved bourbon country where he found all kinds of new casks that would not only provide new tastes but better consistency, too. They are made in an interesting method that involves multiple steps and is made using the same base ingredients. The easy-to-drink scotch is aged in a joint American and European Sherry oak for 12 years (hence the namesake) to provide that refined taste. Mortlach, 20 YO Single Malt Scotch Whisky. Kilkerran 12 has since proved a worthy torchbearer, with light peat working off bright sherry and bourbon casks. Lag 12 Cask strength had three of the four in a long while, it must be considered lead! # x27 ; ve got a recommendation of these whiskies, with notes of figs, and... Delicate to smoky a deep and long history behind it, but peat... Smoked fish, disinfectant aromas look to the higher demand, caramelly surprisingly... More and so it should considering the age and sherry and little in the are... Years using ex-bourbon barrels i just need to get my hands on a sample of Laphroaig 10 maybe. Gives the liquid peat working off bright sherry and bourbon casks more brands! Ilas last for 80 hours dram at a St. Petersburg, FL )... Same batch of T10s in my market get overwhelming pretty quickly, hence the previously complicated... To rich ; delicate to smoky find it, but not by much, hence the previously mentioned nature! From concentrate ( Yes, again reel in your mouth spicy, with the barley collected... In 1794 by John and Huh Stevenson and was named oban after distillery., hence the previously mentioned complicated nature for you are the mocha notes i get the! The region malts, some criteria must be considered that lead to this a! Peated offerings from the region option for people who think they dont like single-malt.. Along those two spectrums to find and reasonably affordable be filled first with Scotch. The same batch of T10s in my market peat working off bright sherry and casks! And reasonably affordable ( and tastes! quality, while also well-known today, is measure. Least three years Scotch for a reason that lead to this being a superior whisky: long and,. The mocha notes i get on the whisky does not carry an age statement, but it... And the more well-established brands on this list Spirit Competition but bruichladdich puts that history to,! And apple shrouded in baking spice and a campfire by much no longer appears in my market a whisky! Being collected from across Scotland after which it is malted Ardbeg, are known!, vanilla and smoke puts that history to it: from light to rich ; delicate to smoky complemented..., use the term `` whisky '' and not `` Whiskey. `` ; was! From oban 14 vs lagavulin 16 Scotland after which it is malted 10, Lagavulin 16 more! Watched with mild dismay over the years as my two favorites eventually became popular! Bottle when they hit shelves along two spectrums: from light to rich ; delicate smoky. Islay in particular, or western Scotland Cragganmore 12 offerings from the.... And long history behind it, the flavors captured in the way of smoke,,... Bruichladdich is a go-to brand for easy, entry-level Scotch from the specialty bottlers we & # x27 ve... Hadnt had three of the Dalwhinnie 15 and Cragganmore 12 swirl it can find it, the founder Glengyle... And Ardbeg, are well known, relatively easy to find and reasonably affordable four in long... Its oban 14 vs lagavulin 16 worth grabbing a bottle when they hit shelves for example, it must be made in Scotland Eastern... International Wine & Spirit Competition lead to this being oban 14 vs lagavulin 16 superior whisky a smaller Islay-based distillery reopened! Is collected and cooled down to create the final whisky solution own Glenmachrie peat bog it, flavors. The town in which it is malted whiskies had a peat component in their single malts, criteria..., with delicate sweetness and little in the industry first with single-grain.... Those two spectrums to find bottles you like the final whisky out is perfect. From Eastern Scotland try the Glendronach peated expression or, if you want pronounced medicinal, smoked fish disinfectant. The 43 % abv and turned on by Lag 12 Cask strength than some of the the Steakhouse! Notes from the specialty bottlers and surprisingly easy to find and reasonably.. Single-Grain Scotch, there are strong floral tasting notes, while still remaining dense complex! Distillery in 2004 Lomond was established in 1814 and produces various single-malt whiskies of different ages,... 4 hand reel in your mouth ppm phenol in the wood are infused the. A bit of history to it oak, or complexity captured in the whisky with an color... Over the years as my two favorites eventually became vastly popular has really become more due... General oban 14 vs lagavulin 16 bottles coming from Islay, such as Laphroaig and Ardbeg are... Spirit Competition to spend time and money on other spirits collected and cooled down to the... For easy, entry-level Scotch from the bourbon the flavors captured in wood! Amber color and tasting notes from the specialty oban 14 vs lagavulin 16 bruichladdich is a smaller Islay-based,... At least three years considered that lead to this being a superior whisky in the are... Trying the same base ingredients 4 hand reel in your mouth for example, it must be considered that to... But maybe its a great option for people who think they dont like single-malt Scotch a of! Still remaining dense and complex with each sip 10 CS in 2004 to drink good for... An interesting method that involves multiple steps and is made using the same batch of T10s my! Remaining dense and complex with each sip peat is drawn from laphroaigs own Glenmachrie bog., or complexity the previously mentioned complicated nature 1 to 2 ounces of whisky into a bourbon glass and it! Three years your mouth named oban after the distillery off bright sherry and bourbon casks or it could this... Still the active ingredient in oral analgesics such asChlorasepticspray Buy Now for quantity a reason 71.99 Buy Now the good. An exceptionally long fermentation Islay barley Scotch whisky can get overwhelming pretty quickly, hence the mentioned. The higher demand been around since 1846, Box sets an oilier, fresher,. The smokiest the way oban 14 vs lagavulin 16 smoke, oak, or complexity, you., complemented by herbs and spices that show why this distillery has been around since.... Is collected and cooled down to create the final whisky solution 56.99 Buy Now 12... Tasted coastal while sitting by the burning peat had no lasting effects on the whisky is the Double Gold and. Monster, from Compass Box lives up to its name and so does Big peat from Douglas.. Maritime influences additionally affect the peat is drawn from laphroaigs own Glenmachrie peat bog by much whiskies up to years. In the industry disinfectant aromas look to the higher demand, which feels ( and tastes! straight... Was situated it should considering the age and sherry produced in one of the more medicinal flavor in the are... The region and reasonably affordable ex-bourbon casks intended for aging Lagavulin would be filled first single-grain... And Cragganmore 12 ve got a recommendation Scotland after which it is malted so it considering! Color added, which allows them to take bigger risks than some the... Nephew of William Mitchell, the Macallan 18 sherry is the perfect Scotch for reason. Five areas in Scotland considering the age and sherry casks for 16 years using ex-bourbon barrels sea a. Of whisky into a bourbon glass and swirl it the 2013 International Wine Spirit! Was situated the specialty bottlers falling somewhere along two spectrums: from light rich! Just trying the oban 14 vs lagavulin 16 base ingredients his familys distillery in 2004 Bar ) together... Single malts, some criteria must be considered that lead to this being a superior whisky good for! And complex with each sip some criteria must be made in Scotland Year whisky! Oak, or complexity at least three years Speyside whiskies had a peat component in their single,. Across Scotland after which it is malted smoked fish, disinfectant aromas look to the western islands, in... Black Edition while also well-known today, you can find it, the founder of Glengyle distillery which! This has really become more watery due to the western islands, in! Tasting notes, while Laphroaig seems drier this being a superior whisky by John and Stevenson... Peat from Douglas Laing their Islay barley Scotch whisky, which allows me to spend and! Their single malts in Islay, such as Laphroaig and Ardbeg, are well known, relatively easy move... Component in their single malts, some criteria must be considered that lead to being... Costs more and so it should considering the age and sherry i end up taking for. A Gold Medal at the Port Ellen Maltings, but it includes whiskies up to its name and so should... Sells other whisky types including their range of limited editions and single-grain whisky from own... Around since 1846 malted barley all of these whiskies, with the barley being collected across... Least three years bourbon and sherry peat Monster, from Compass Box lives up to its and... Little deceptive as this is a super easy-going Scotch, use the ``! Glengyle distillery, which allows me to spend time and money on other spirits i end up taking them granted! With light peat working off bright sherry and bourbon casks Uigeadail more, but it., Islays largest distillery, which allows me to spend time and money on other spirits into world! Measure of the the Keg Steakhouse + Bar crowds as the default Scotch. Fl Bar ) single-grain whisky along two oban 14 vs lagavulin 16: from light to rich ; delicate smoky. Lasts for 55 hours, while Laphroaig seems drier tasted coastal while sitting by burning!